Falcons Mailbag: What to make of Atlanta's recent roster decisions

Tori McElhaney

FLOWERY BRANCH, Ga. I think we all knew this week was going to be a crazy one, right? There were too many metaphorical balls in the air for it not to be. And between the Falcons leaning on nearly every possible designation to keep guys from hitting the waiver wire, coupled withmore news on injuriesand their ramifications, along with trades and signing? Phew. It's been a doozy of the week.

Some questions have been answered since the last time we spoke via this mailbag, but others remain. Let's go through a few of the ones you all still have.

From @RiseUpReader on X/Twitter

Will the RT situation derail our season? Losing Kaleb McGary and Storm Norton is devastating.

If a right tackle situation derails your entire season then you did not have a strong enough roster to begin with. So, the question feels a tad dramatic for me if I am being completely honest.

Now, is losing McGary and Norton concerning? Yes. It is. But you still have four of five starters returning from last year's line to this year's group because yes,I do consider Ryan Neuzil a starterseeing as he played nearly equal games as Drew Dalman did in 2024. That's still more than a lot of offensive lines across the league when comparing their plight.

I will add that as long as you have Chris Lindstrom on the right side, he has the talent to make up for a lot of other players' deficiencies. I know people are concerned about Michael Penix Jr.'s blindside. But they were concerned about that when it was McGary slated to be the blindside protector, and honestly, even he said he wasn't concerned about it considering the nature of offenses nowadays. Modern offenses dictate that at some point? A quarterback is going to have his back to one side or another, and it's not always his natural blindside.

I also think it is some times easier to cover up a deficiencies at tackle because you can put a tight end beside him, or you have a running back chipping the edge rusher. Heck, maybe the Falcons will deploy a few more 12 personnel looks to add more oomph on the offensive line.

Regardless, this tackle situation is not the end of the world, but it definitely isn't great. I will give you that.

From @DavidJo2437 on X/Twitter

What's going on with Troy Andersen?

Andersen on is on reserve/PUP still working through the knee injury that he sustained last season. Raheem Morris has not provided an update on his return yet. However, we do know that reserve/PUP rules dictate that a player must miss the first four games of the season before they can return to the field of play. So, the earliest anyone will see Andersen even suit up for Atlanta would be after the team's Week 5 bye.

Still, even that timeline is speculation on my part.

From @AtlasPryme and @chat85982 on X/Twitter

Why was Khalid Kareem not elevated from the PS to fill in for Bralen Trice going on IR? | Why a safety to replace an edge rusher/OLB?

Elevations from the practice squad are not one for one. Just because you lose an edge rusher does not mean you have to or even want to replace them on the 53-man roster with another. It's a numbers game, and at the time of the Falcons' placement of Trice on IR, the numbers were in edge rushers' favor.

Prior tosigning Jordan Fuller to their active roster, Falcons were only carrying three safeties (Jessie Bates, Xavier Watts and DeMarcco Hellams). You usually like to keep that number safely around four. Meanwhile, they were carrying five edge rushers outside of Trice, which I deem to be a pretty healthy number for the position for the time being.

The Falcons did not feel they needed to replace Trice's number on the 53-man roster with another edge rusher when they needed that number for the safety position. It's as simple as that.

Now, as for Kareem: I have no doubt you'll see him again. Heck, you could see him active as a practice squad elevation come Week 1's matchup with the Buccaneers. So, don't worry about this decision too much.

From @KeyshawnVlad on X/Twitter

With all the DBs we have on the roster, do you believe there will be a lot of dime formations from our defense?

At this point in time, no. I don't think you're going to see the Falcons rolling through a lot of dime looks. Now, could I be eating my words come Week 1 with Baker Mayfield attempting to take the top off this defense? Sure. But I think that is really the only time in certain situations against certain looks will the Falcons roll in a dime package. I don't see it being their go-to look though.

I don't think this will be the case because of one person in particular: Divine Deablo. He's not someone very many people have talked about this preseason, but he is someone who I think matters a great deal to this defense. He's a former college safety turned linebacker, so we know his coverage skills are there. Do you really need another defensive back in the secondary to do something Deablo is efficient in? I don't think so.

Now, could you run out a look that includes DeMarcco Hellams as a big safety? Maybe even closer to the box? Sure. But again, to your question of whether or not I believe they'll run out six defensive backs "a lot" no I really don't think they will. I think we will see it at times, but not with a frequency that is astronomically different than last year.

Up Next

Videos

Michael Jarrell, Kaden Elliss & other Falcons on their expectations for the upcoming season

Videos

Exclusive interview on Atlanta Falcons' 2025 initial roster with General Manager Terry Fontenot

Videos

Michael Penix Jr. & Drake London Media Availability | Thursday, Aug. 28th | Press Conference

Videos

Atlanta Falcons Head Coach Raheem Morris Media Availability | Thursday, Aug 28th | Press Conference

Videos

Instant reactions to Atlanta Falcons' 2025 initial roster + Offensive Line news | Atlanta Falcons Podcast

Videos

Liam McCullough is mic'd up in final preseason game vs the Dallas Cowboys

Videos

Head Coach Raheem Morris reflects on final preseason game against Dallas Cowboys | Press Conference

Videos

Falcons vs. Cowboys highlights | Preseason Week 3

Videos

Elijah Dotson explodes down the sidelines for 41-yard run

Videos

Easton Stick does it himself for 12-yard gain and first down

Videos

Easton Stick's 23-TD connection with Feleipe Franks trims Cowboys' lead to 14-9

Videos

Josh Woods' hit-stick tackle ends Cropper's punt return abruptly

Videos

Younghoe Koo drills 38-yard field goal to get Falcons on the board

Videos

Easton Stick lofts pass to Nick Nash for 15-yard gain down sideline

Videos

Easton Stick connects with Nick Nash down the middle for 24-yard gain

Videos

Marquice Williams is mic'd up for AT&T Training Camp

Videos

Best of Defensive Line Highlights | Highlights | 2025 AT&T Training Camp | NFL

Videos

Kaleb McGary injury raises questions at OT & players on the 53-man bubble | Atlanta Falcons Podcast

Videos

C.J. Henderson & other Falcons on preparing for the final preseason game of 2025

Videos

Raheem Morris on preparation for Atlanta Falcons vs Dallas Cowboys road matchup | Press Conference

Videos

Ruke Orhorhoro is mic'd up at AT&T Training Camp

Videos

Kaden Elliss is mic'd up for joint practice with the Tennessee Titans | AT&T Training Camp

Videos

Casey Washington, A.J. Terrell Jr. & other Falcons at the start of week 4 of camp

Videos

Offensive Coordinator Zac Robinson Media Availability | Monday, August 18th | Atlanta Falcons

Videos

Chris Blair, Natrone Brooks & other Falcons after the preseason game against the Tennessee Titans

Videos

Raheem Morris reflects on Falcons vs Titans preseason game | Press Conference

Videos

Titans vs. Falcons Preseason Week 2 highlights

Videos

Can't-Miss Play: 52-yard TD! Stick's deep strike lands in Blair's mitts for six

Videos

Can't-Miss Play: 43-yard TD! Nathan Carter looks like an Olympic sprinter on speedy score

Videos

Younghoe Koo gets Falcons on the board with 42-yard field goal

Videos

Natrone Brooks flies in for interception off Brandon Allen's pass

Videos

Chris Long says the Falcons are "must watch" TV & explains why the defense can improve | Podcast

Videos

All Juice No Brakes | The James Pearce Jr. Story | Rookie Spotlight | Atlanta Falcons

Videos

A.J. Terrell Jr. is mic'd up for joint practices with the Tennessee Titans | AT&T Training Camp

Videos

Nate Ollie is mic'd up at AT&T Training Camp | "You Think You Stink" | Atlanta Falcons | NFL

Videos

Highlights | When two teams collide | Falcons x Titans Joint Practice | 2025 AT&T Training Camp

Videos

What you need to watch for in the Falcons' next preseason game + Wes Durham shares his 2025 insights

Videos

Quarterback Michael Penix Jr Falcons & Titans Joint Practice Day Two | Press Conference

Videos

James Pearce Jr. & others on day 2 of joint practice with the Tennessee Titans

Videos

Head Coach Raheem Morris Falcons & Titans Joint Practice Day Two Press Conference | Atlanta Falcons

More Raleigh News

Access More

Sign up for Raleigh News

a daily newsletter full of things to discuss over drinks.and the great thing is that it's on the house!